$7.2 Billion In U.S. Subsidies Can’t Keep Southwest In The Air For Christmas

Southwest stole Christmas for tens of thousands of its passengers

Photo credit: Carlos Yudica - stock.adobe.com

TOPLINE:

Southwest Airlines received $7.2 billion in federal subsidies for payroll and operations since 2020. However, the airline stranded tens of thousands of passengers around the country on the Christmas holiday when it canceled 5,400 flights in less than 48 hours. Our auditors at OpenTheBooks.com verified the federal aid using government disclosures.

Review each earmark mapped by state using our interactive map at OpenTheBooks.com. Just click a pin (state capitol) and then scroll down to see the results rendered in the chart beneath the map.

WHAT HAPPENED:

Southwest is blaming the failure on a crash of its internal systems that schedule flight crews and pilots. A union for Southwest Airlines flight attendants attributed the meltdown to outdated scheduling systems that should have been upgraded years ago.

FEDS ANNOUNCE INVESTIGATION:

Late yesterday, the U.S. Department of Transportation announced that it opened a federal investigation into the airline. The USDOT cited concern about an “unacceptable rate of cancellations and delays and reports of lack of prompt customer service.”

Indeed. The Southwest mobile app, phone lines, and website were offline for much of yesterday afternoon and evening. In major hubs like Chicago Midway, some in-person customer service personnel walked off the job with hundreds of stranded passengers waiting to reschedule cancelled flights.

Once bags were checked, the bags flew to final destinations even though no flights were available for canceled passengers. Stranded passengers found this baggage policy completely unacceptable – passengers were not able to reclaim checked luggage after flights were cancelled.

It was absolute chaos for thousands and a logistical nightmare for the airline that won’t be solved for weeks.

Southwest canceled flights at Midway Airport, Chicago, Illinois on December 26, 2022 at 5:30pm

GOVERNMENT SUBSIDIES SINCE 2020

Where could Southwest have found the money to upgrade their systems?

In September 2020, as part of massive COVID relief packages, Southwest received a $3.3 billion from the federal government. The government received stock agreements as a mechanism to partially recoup taxpayer money, however, those warrants are worth only a small fraction of the overall subsidy payments.

In April 2021, as a part of the American Rescue Plan Act and other subsidies, Southwest received another $3.8 billion, according to data on the federal transparency website and disclosed company 10-K reports to Wall Street.

In total, federal aid to the entire airline industry amounted to $64 billion in cash and loans during the Covid-period. The subsidies were meant to backstop the entire airline industry which had been decimated.

Aid was conditional on employee retainment, restrictions of executive compensation, and pausing stock dividends and buybacks. While some of the aid was technically a loan, for example, Southwest only has to pay back 30% of the first $3.3 billion ($976 million) at a low interest rate over a ten year period.

Southwest received so much federal aid, they turned a net income profit of $116 million by Q1 2021. They were the first airline to return to profitability after the pandemic.

“While the pandemic is not over, we believe the worst is behind us, in terms of the severity of the negative impact on travel demand,” Chairman and CEO Gary Kelly said in a statement (April 2021).

Other airlines were also received their cut of pandemic aid, of course, with the Treasury awarding over $37 billion of the first $54 billion in payroll support to the top ten airlines alone.

During the 2022 Christmas holiday period, those airlines were able to keep their planes flying, by and large.

Disclosure: Southwest 10-K reporting of federal subsidies.

QUOTABLE:

" My name is Gary Kelly, and I’m privileged to serve as Chairman and CEO at Southwest Airlines. Thank you for inviting me to testify on behalf of the 54,000 active Southwest Employees who directly benefitted from the Payroll Support Program (PSP). I can sum up the PSP in two words: IT WORKED. Our Employees have endured unprecedented challenges over the last two years—from new federal requirements to unruly passengers— and I couldn’t be more proud of them. Their resilience and resolve are nothing short of heroic. PSP secured their jobs, their pay, and their benefits.

Testimony to Congress, December 15, 2021

CRITICS:

Thousands of stranded passengers are taking to social media to raise their voices and tell their stories. Like missing their father’s funeral, missing their cruises, losing thousands of dollars; and some have had up to five flights cancelled. The emotional stories of anguish seem endless.

Read the stories and share your own on the Southwest Instagram.

ABOUT US:

OpenTheBooks.com – We believe transparency is transformational. Using forensic auditing and open records, we hold government accountable. In 2022, we filed 50,000+ FOIA requests and successfully captured $12 trillion government expenditures: nearly all federal spending; 50 state checkbooks; and 25 million public employee salary and pension records from 50,000 public bodies across America. Our works have been featured on the BBC, Good Morning America, ABC World News Tonight, The Wall Street Journal, USA Today, Chicago Tribune, The New York Times, NBC News, FOX News, Forbes, National Public Radio (NPR), Sinclair Broadcast Group, & many others.

Our organization accepts no taxpayer funding and was founded by CEO Adam Andrzejewski. Our federal oversight work was cited twice in the President's Budget To Congress FY2021. Andrzejewski's presentation, The Depth of the Swamp, at the Hillsdale College National Leadership Seminar 2020 in Naples, Florida posted on YouTube received 3.8 million views.

NOTICE: We reserve the right to remove comments that deemed offensive to our organization, staff, and audience.